"Gender-Free" Dance? Is that one of them new organic food labels?
/No, it's not an FDA label letting you know you are federally protected from some harmful substance, but it does identify an ingredient we don't often think about: the role gender plays in why we dance.
Ultimately, I want to define the purpose of a Gender-Free dance.
When I first started working on this event with PCDC, I asked around for some opinions on the matter, and, not surprisingly, some folks said, “ah, that's just those young people who don't know themselves forcing me to change some terms that don't mean anything.” This might sound like a generational divide...because it is. But I want to honor the underlying fear/push back from this kind of statement. Every generation, every person, wants to feel comfortable and accepted in their identity of self. To have someone tell you you've gotten your ideas of gender wrong your whole life, and without even having a conversation with you, well, that's just plain mean. Why, you'd never do such a....thing... would you?
After all, a safe place for anyone to be themselves and share in the joy of contra dance is one of our most cherished talking points in dance evangelism, right?
Enter, the Gender-Free dance (which we still haven't defined). To some, Gender-Free dances are a “gay friendly” dance. Closer would be a dance intending to cultivate a safe space for all people – specifically to be more open to queer and trans community members, whom we love and who stopped coming to dances.
But neither is what I believe defines a Gender-Free dance. A Gender-Free dance should address why folks feel left out of our community promise, right? And just saying, “hey, we are lgbtq friendly tonight” doesn't make it so. So, what is it folks are drawn to Gender-Free dances all across the country?
Let me start by saying thank you to everyone who shared their experience, insights and, often, strong opinions. The two main themes that arose out of my conversations were: 1. We have been saying “guys can dance with guys,” and “girls can dance with girls,” for awhile now but, really, we've been modeling “girls dance with girls because they have to, and guys dancing with guys is gross.” And 2. The reasons why different people contra dance don't always match.
Be it in a Gender-Free dance or not, number one is clearly hurtful and is easy enough to fix. If we honor the choices of our community members to be and play whatever role they choose, then we are upholding our values of openness and welcoming as a dance community (freedom of identity). We can change terms or not, or redefine terms to mean what we want them to (that is another conversation), face our own phobias (yet another conversation), but ultimately, honoring wherever someone has chosen to dance clearly falls at the center of accepting community members free of gender. Step 1.
Number two was much more surprising. Thank you, again, to all the folks who were open in our conversations. I had many conversations with folks around the disappointment they would feel, and the glaze that would come over their eyes, when dancing with the fourth “same gendered” person in the line. I thought is was strait up queer/trans phobia, but it is not. That exists, for some, but there were a whole mess of “older” friends and community members who shared an insight I hadn't even considered.
“I like dancing with guys (girls) from time to time, in the line, but I come to flirt with women (or men). That is the reason I dance. If I only dance with guys (girls) in an evening, it wasn't worth it for me.” Some younger folks might balk, but those are the same folks who will grow old, say young people just don't understand how to live not understand why said young people look at them funny. It's true! Flirting with your desired sex/gender is one of the primary reasons our dance form exists – to have fun as a community and meet partners, friends, lovers, and dance (celebration/fun/etc.) as a community.
The difference for most younger folks, especially where the generational divide is greater, is that they don't dance to flirt or find partnership. Sure, a bit, but that is what blues or swing or tango is for. In contra, they dance more often just to dance with everyone (or their friends) – to be themselves (awkward and all) and have fun with the whole community. It's not a more noble reason than any other, and we all dance for this reason too. It is just a different major focus, so younger folks aren't going to feel welcome when us “older” folks give them the stink eye for “confusing the line with their gender bending.”
So, what does all this mean for defining “what is a Gender-Free dance?”
Well, Gender-free is not just about the terms we use to include folks who don't identify as male or female (which will be more accurate and including if we do, learning curve aside). It is not just about being more open and welcoming to all folks regardless of sexual or gender identity (which it is a reminder of). Gender-free dances are about cultivating one of our primary reasons for dancing, the reason our next generation of dancers will be drawn to – to enjoy the whole of the community first and other reasons after.
I'll leave you with a quote from someone who came specifically because they had fallen in love with our dance community, someone who hadn't been back for a long time and articulated the draw for the next generation:
“...For me, I feel this sense of community, togetherness, learning to laugh about mistakes. I see friends and strangers alike coming together to experience something so basic and yet profound that has been lost in the larger culture. For me, it is a joyful celebration of the human experience, and my hope is that everyone who wants to participate gets to feel welcomed with open arms and big smiles, invitations to dance, and language that includes them...”